Forum Archive Index - October 2003

[fntradingsolutions <fntrade@bigpond.net.au>]

Who wants to resolve the truth! Debate man! therein lies the rub!

I am trying to action a debate on the subject and the reply's are everything BUT!

Debate is the ultimate human learning tool, ever since its meager bicameral beginnings. The debates between Einstein and Rosen are legendary. Their issues were also never resolved, BUT the many outcomes gave birth to Quantum Physics.

Lets debate the issue here and to hell with resolving it.

Woody

----- Original Message -----

From: david.gibson

To: sharechat@sharechat.co.nz

Sent: Monday, October 13, 2003 8:58 AM

Subject: RE: [sharechat] TA/FA Debate!

The TA/FA debate has been running since the beginning of continuous auction markets.  Posting to this list is NOT "a search for the truth" and I doubt we will ever resolve the debate, one way or another, here.

 

As Socrates said "the unexamined life is not worth living".  That is the point of the list - people who have the courage to express a view are doing everyone a favour.  "Fronting up" with your ideas and conducting a process of examination is what the list is all about.

 

No one who posts here is stupid!  (We have all done battle with Microsoft products, ISP services; to get this far - and have won).

 

People who engage with a Parthian shot are cowards!  (They may have "truth" on their side - but the key is participation).

 

As a final thought - perhaps the diversity of opinion expressed in the list reflects the wider market.  There are tidal flows of "opinion of value" that underpin what happens in real markets.  It is better to face diverse views, integrate them into your strategies, and adapt - than to face the world with a fixed point of view.