By Jenny Ruth
Monday 25th April 2011 |
Text too small? |
The Commerce Commission's surprise move to change its regulatory goalposts for electricity lines companies earlier this month effectively reduces Vector's value by 5%, says Grant Swanepoel, an analyst at Craigs Investment Partners.
The effect of the Commerce Commission's change in thinking is that, under its previous guidelines, firms were able to earn about an 8.7% return on assets after tax before any price adjustment was made but now the allowable rate of return is only 7.7%.
"We believe that this change means that Vector would need to cut prices by 7% (including a 1% claw back) in regulatory year 2012," Swanepoel says. "We had assumed a 4% total cut in prices."
"This change continues to highlight the regulatory uncertainty around this company. . . the change is extremely negative for Vector," he says.
Vector's electricity lines business accounts for about 65% of earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation.
Swanepoel is expecting Vector to report a $197 million net profit for the year ending June but has cut his 2012 forecast from $176 million to $171 million and his 2013 forecast from $178 million to $170 million.
He has cut his valuation of Vector shares by 5% to $2.55.
Another key uncertainty is whether Vector can secure gas supply contracts for its wholesale gas business, he says.
Recommendation: hold.
No comments yet
Vector ekes out 2.3% gain in FY profit as technology unit bolsters earnings
Vector may beat guidance for FY 2013, suffer 2014 earnings drop
Vector cleared to buy Contact Energy's gas metering business for $63M
Vector to cut gas distribution prices by 18 percent
Vector 1H result up 10.8 percent in flat economy
ComCom takes issue with Vector on regulated rates of return
Vector credit rating may come under scrutiny
Vector profit steady, underpined by revenue growth
Long-running battle over power line prices coming to a head
Vector appoints Beddoe as chief risk officer